The Whisky Lover’s Guide to Apple Brandy

When you learned about the American folklore hero John Chapman, nom de pomme Johnny Appleseed, in grade school, they probably didn’t tell you he was propagating apple trees throughout the country to make cider and brandy, not for lunchbox snacks. Apple brandy, historically known as applejack, is America’s original spirit. Long before the birth of bourbon, colonial Americans used freeze distillation, a decidedly low-tech precursor to modern techniques, to preserve their apple harvest in liquid form. A century later, Robert Laird, a Revolutionary War soldier, gave his recipe for apple brandy to George Washington. Laird went on to found America’s first commercial distillery, Laird & Co., which still makes apple brandy under family ownership two and a half centuries later.

Take A Bite Out of These Apple Brandies

Cider and apple brandy were a cornerstone of American drinking until Prohibition, when apple brandy largely fell off the map. Laird & Co. soldiered on alone for most of the 20th century. “We kept apple brandy alive all these years,” says company vice president Lisa Laird Dunn. “When I was younger, when I said my family made applejack, people thought I meant the cereal.” Restoring applejack to its rightful place in our drinking lexicon may seem like a tall order, but it’s almost low-hanging fruit given the renewed interest in classic cocktails and the emergence of craft distilling. “Apple brandy is like American apple pie,” says Joe Heron, founder of the Louisville, Ky.-based brandy distiller Copper & Kings. “It’s so much more familiar than people realize. It’s got that kind of crossover heritage appeal, a Marlboro man type of masculinity and adventurousness.”

How ’Bout Them Apples

The whisky world relies heavily on barrel aging for its flavors. Not so for American apple brandy, which has no oak aging requirement. When aged in oak for just a year or two, or not at all, American apple brandies taste like an apple in a glass, bursting at the seams with fresh, juicy, fruity flavors. Older apple brandies, with a decade or more of maturation, achieve more whisky-like flavors of rich oak spice, clove, and vanilla. The best examples always retain the essence of their fruit source.

Try This Cocktail: Jack Rose

While there are thousands of varieties of apples, those used for American brandy fall into two wide camps: culinary apples (the sort you buy in the grocery store and would actually want to eat) or traditional cider apples and other heirloom varieties that may be too bitter, too tart, too crisp to bite into. In Normandy, distillers of the French apple brandy Calvados draw upon hundreds of named traditional cider apples to create a rustic, subtle, and delicate spirit. Most American distillers take the culinary route—it’s simply what’s available. “There aren’t enough cider apples in America to make very much brandy,” says Heron of Copper & Kings, which uses culinary apples. “We aren’t trying to be Calvados. We’re much more interested in an American sensibility—more robust, richer, more fruit, with warmer tones.” Likewise, Clear Creek Distillery in Oregon prefers widely available Golden Delicious apples for their juicy and fruity flavor. “It has this apple-y quality that can be showcased really proudly in the spirit in a way that other varieties couldn’t,” says head distiller Joseph O’Sullivan.

Some distilleries, like Laird & Co. and Chicago-based Rhine Hall Distillery, blend many different types of culinary apples together. Others combine both culinary and traditional distilling varieties. A few—like one of the oldest craft distilleries in the country, California-based Germain-Robin, which buys heirloom apples from historic orchards with century-old trees in the Anderson Valley—prefer traditional apples for their exceptional balance. “When we pick, we get a ton of flavor, but the apples still have enough acidity to give it definition and structure. Culinary apples tend not to have enough acidity… the flavors are a little too soft,” says founder Ansley Coale.

Try This Cocktail: Apple Brandy Old Fashioned

Apple selection is just one way apple brandy achieves its diversity of styles. As with whisky, distillers are exploring new flavors through techniques like unusual cask finishes (tequila-finished apple brandy, anyone?). Others are planting heritage cider-apple trees and rediscovering lost traditions. In Apple Belt states like New York, Michigan, and Washington, a growing number of small farm distilleries are using their own crops to make rustic, traditional apple brandy with a sense of place, reviving a lost taste of America that Johnny Appleseed might recognize today.

More From Insights

The Truth About Big Box Whiskies

Costco, Trader Joe’s, Total Wine, and Walmart have their own private-label scotch and bourbon. We investigated whether these whiskies are worth your money.

Can Bourbon Be Too Old?

Pappy Van Winkle 23 is a benchmark for many, but not every whiskey tastes good after two decades in the barrel.