87

Score

Gordon & MacPhail (distilled at Caol Ila), 8 year old, 1996 vintage, 58.1%

Price: $55.00 Issue: Fall 2006 Reviewer: John Hansell

The Islay character is most evident in the younger whisky expressions, before the oak has tamed them. This whisky is a perfect example: an uninhibited, incredibly powerful Caol Ila, thumping out notes of tarry rope, damp peat, kippers, and seaweed. Background spices (salt, pepper, ginger) add intrigue, while a firm foundation of vanilla malt struggles to provide soothing comfort. Extreme Islay whisky. (A Binny’s Beverage Depot exclusive.)