91

Score

High West The Prisoner's Share Red Wine Barrel Finished Blend of Straights, 51%

Price: 175 Issue: Summer 2026 Reviewer: David Fleming Category: Blended American Whiskey

A blend of bourbon and rye finished in wine barrels that previously held The Prisoner red blend from California, as both brands are owned by Constellation Brands. The color is on the darker side, but the nose offers lighter aromas of vanilla frosting and cream puff. The palate is fruity, with luscious jammy flavors of red berries and orange, followed by more of the same on a long finish.