92

Score

Lost Lantern Single Cask Series Montgomery Distillery, 52.3%

Price: 100 ● Issue: Fall 2026 ● Reviewer: Jonny McCormick ● Category: Rye Whiskey

This comes at you with a haymaker nose of oak, barrel char, cherry cheesecake, chocolate-covered berries, and Dr Pepper. The palate leads with more oak, peanut brittle, and chewy Chips Ahoy amid spices like cinnamon stick, chai, and pepper. The tannins recede on the finish, revealing black cherry, Ghirardelli dark chocolate, vanilla cream, and leather at the very end. Powerful from start to finish, but carries its proof very well.