Autumn in NY is Here and It's Time for WhiskyFest! Use Code FallForWhisky for Extra Ticket Savings.

92

Score

Macaloney's Signature Selection Siol Dugall Canadian Island Peated Single Malt (Batch 2), 46%

Price: 82 Issue: Fall 2024 Reviewer: Julia Higgins Category: Canadian

Delightful tendrils of sweet peat waft from the glass, with vanilla bean, campfire coals, burnt marshmallow, and a hint of fresh guava taking center stage. Similarly soft and sweet flavors arise on the palate, which is light on its feet; eventually, a well-balanced mix of peppery spice, chocolate, and ashy charcoal emerges. The finish marks a turn toward even more peated earthiness, though lovely notes of lemon cake and pepper remain.