Whisky Advocate's Top 20 Whiskies of 2025 Have Been Announced! Start Your Holiday Shopping!

88

Score

O'Danagher's American (Batch 1), 45%

Price: 65 Issue: Spring 2016 Reviewer: Lew Bryson Category: American Whiskey

This Dry Fly Distilling project is made from grains grown in Washington by farmer Tim O'Danaher [note that different spellings are correct]. Off to a good start: a luxuriously sweet cereal aroma puffs out of the glass as I pour, and adds softened dried fruits and hard candy when actively nosed. The new American oak (53-gallon barrel) is evident immediately, tempering the sweetness with spice, walnuts, and a hard woodiness. Finish is long, balanced, enticing. Definitely enjoyable as a sipper; an interesting new direction.