84

Score

Pappy Van Winkle 23 year old Family Reserve, 47.8%

Price: $200 Issue: Winter 2005 Reviewer: John Hansell

Broodingly thick and syrupy in texture, and quite dry-especially on the finish. Twenty-three years is a long time for bourbon to spend in oak, and this one shows its age. The flavors and complexity of its younger two siblings is evident until mid-palate, but then dwindles slightly as the whisky progresses, replaced by dry, spicy, leathery, sooty-charcoal, tobacco notes.