Whisky Advocate's Top 20 Whiskies of 2025 Have Been Announced! Start Your Holiday Shopping!

91

Score

Shenk's Homestead Kentucky Sour Mash (2025 Release), 45.6%

Price: 110 Issue: Winter 2025 Reviewer: Shane English Category: Blended American Whiskey

Part of Michter’s Legacy Series, this sour mash is partially finished in toasted but not charred French oak barrels. On the nose, there’s caramel, hot chocolate, and French toast, creating a pleasantly sweet but straightforward aroma. The sip is all chocolate desserts: chocolate sauce, freshly baked brownies, and chocolate-covered cherries. With a little water, apple fritters and gingersnaps emerge. The chocolate notes continue on the finish, with a hint of charred oak adding depth.