Valentine Distilling Co. 15 year old Mayor Pingree “Black Label,” 57%

Upon first smell, rich milk chocolate fills the nose, alongside peanuts, peanut brittle, and raspberry jam. The palate balances bright red fruit alongside darker, deeper flavors—think dark-chocolate raspberry squares, chocolate-covered Bing cherries, and dark-roast coffee. There are richer flavors here, too, with butterscotch and an oaky component emerging at the back end. A long-lasting finish that highlights more wood influence, some cocoa, and espresso luxuriously ties up this satisfying sipper. (684 bottles)