91
Score
Very Olde St. Nick Immaculata Ancient Cask, 59.1%
Price: ● Issue: Fall 2026 ● Reviewer: Danny Brandon ● Category: Bourbon/Tennessee Whiskey
A chocoholic’s Shangri-La on the nose, with double chocolate brownies, fudge, crushed Oreos, and chocolate-covered pretzels alongside plum, raisin, and black cherries. The palate has applesauce, fresh peaches, ripe pears, strawberry jam, and raspberry, all held up by a rock-solid foundation of butterscotch and oak. The long finish adds grapes, sangria, dried apricot, marmalade, and gingersnaps. Captivating flavors and great integration; a bourbon that seems well-suited for scotch lovers.